What Remains of Edith Finch is an atmospheric narrative-driven game developed by Giant Sparrow and published by Annapurna Interactive. Released in 2017, it offers a deeply emotional journey through the Finch family’s dark and tragic history. Below, I’ll discuss the pros and cons of the game to provide a comprehensive understanding of its appeal and limitations.
Pros of What Remains of Edith Finch:
- Engaging Narrative:
- Unique Storytelling: The game is widely celebrated for its innovative storytelling techniques. Each room in the Finch house represents a different family member, and through these rooms, players experience the unique stories of their lives, often ending in bizarre or tragic ways. This non-linear storytelling keeps the narrative fresh and engaging, as players uncover secrets and stories in a way that feels like a puzzle.
- Emotional Depth: The game explores themes of loss, memory, and the passage of time in a profoundly personal way. Each family member’s story is imbued with emotion, making the player feel a deep connection to the characters despite their brief appearances.
- Creative Use of Medium: The game uses various gameplay mechanics to tell its story. From becoming a giantess in a fairy tale to experiencing the terrifying perspective of a cat, each gameplay segment offers a unique perspective that enhances the narrative.
- Atmospheric Design:
- Detailed Environment: The Finch house is more than just a setting; it’s a character in itself. The house’s dark and mysterious ambiance reflects the heavy themes of the game. Every room is filled with artifacts and clues that provide insight into the lives of the Finch family, adding layers of depth to the story.
- Visual and Audio Design: The game’s art style is both haunting and beautiful, complementing the narrative’s emotional tone. The soundtrack, composed by Jeff Russo, is atmospheric and melancholic, further enhancing the mood of the game.
- Interactive Elements:
- Discovery Through Interaction: What Remains of Edith Finch allows players to interact with objects to uncover stories, rather than relying solely on dialogue or text. This hands-on approach to storytelling makes the experience more personal and immersive.
Cons of What Remains of Edith Finch:
- Short Duration:
- Limited Gameplay Time: The game can be completed in a few hours, and due to its linear progression through each family member’s story, there isn’t much replay value. This can leave players wanting more, as they only scratch the surface of the Finch family’s stories.
- Lack of Player Choice:
- Linear Experience: The game’s narrative is heavily linear, which can limit the player’s agency. Each story is set, with few opportunities for players to influence the outcome. This might feel restrictive for players who prefer more control over their gaming experiences.
- Niche Appeal:
- Not for Everyone: What Remains of Edith Finch’s slow pace and heavy narrative focus may not appeal to all gamers, particularly those who prefer action-packed gameplay or games with high replay value. Its introspective and emotional nature can be a barrier for some.
Conclusion:
What Remains of Edith Finch is a powerful and unique narrative experience that excels in storytelling and emotional depth. Its pros lie in its creative use of the medium to tell a deeply personal and evocative story, along with its beautiful and atmospheric design. However, its short duration, linearity, and niche appeal might limit its accessibility and replayability. For players seeking a rich narrative experience, this game is a must-play, but those looking for more varied gameplay or extended engagement might find it lacking.
